Toughie No 3672 by Elgar
Hints and Tips by crypticsue
+ – + – + – + – + – + – + – +
BD Rating – Toughie Difficulty ***** – Enjoyment *****
Exactly what you expect from Elgar’s fortnightly visit to the middle of the paper. As clearly indicated by the clue to 21d, the Across solutions are all hiding items which a 15d might catch
Please let us know what you thought
Across
1a 21 Down eclipsing mashed potato – except to mum (3,1,4)
NOT A PEEP Mum here being an interjection requesting silence. Another Scottish name for the solution to 21d into which is inserted (eclipsing) POTAto (except to indicating the need to omit the last two letters)
5a Like some rum special on the rocks? (6)
SPICED The abbreviation for special and what a drink is when served ‘on the rocks’
9a Deviously work situation left chicken off when eating out (6,2)
WANGLE IT An anagram (out) of WhenEATING without the ‘chicken’
10a Trimming beef, bar worker has cut double (6)
FRINGE The final letter of beeF (without, bar, the worker) and a double without the final letter (cut)
12a It’s rather creepy, chap out of university getting in our fourth drink (6,3)
GROUND IVY An informal name for a chap without (out of) the abbreviation for University into which is inserted (getting in) a set of drinks bought in at one time and the Roman numeral for four

13a Last of bread and cheese is restorative, it’s said (5)
HEELS Bottoms or ends of loaves of bread or pieces of cheese sounds like (it is said) part of a verb meaning is restorative

14a/21a Fray Bentos finally withdrawing their swan in a pie (4,4)
WEAR THIN An anagram (in a pie or mixed state) of THEIR sWAN without the final letter of bentoS
16a Mean gunners tucked into an artichoke perhaps off table (7)
AVERAGE The abbreviation for the Royal Artillery (gunners) ‘tucked’ into what an artichoke is without (off) the TABLE at the end of the word
19a Ruined hut circles on verge of find in allotment? (7)
UNEARTH An anagram (ruined) of HUT ‘circles’ or goes round a simple way of saying on the verge of
21a See 14a
24a Like lobster, maybe, served initially covered in greenery (5)
SPINY The initial letter of Served and covered in greenery from a particular type of tree

25a Film juicy fruit overspreading area in garden? (4,5)
HOME ALONE A type of juice fruit goes round (overspreading) the abbreviation for Area, the result then inserted into a verb meaning to garden with a tool for loosening the earth and digging up weeds
27a Back to front division of e.g. brain protein (6)
GLOBIN Dividing into, for example, the divisions of the brain with the letter at the back moved to the front of the word
28a That has new stuffing for bird (8)
WHINCHAT The abbreviation for New ‘stuffing’ an adjective meaning that has

29a First to table ahead of bunfight, a theme on ship (6)
TEREDO The whole of the solution is part of the theme, this genus found on ships – there’s a hidden themed item there too. The first letter of Table, a literary word meaning before (ahead of) and a party (bunfight)
30a Empty A1 case of advocaat (light bottles) (8)
DEFLATED A slang adjective meaning excellent (A1) and the outside letters (case) of AdvocaaT inserted into (bottles) a type of light
Down
1d Where to find Jarrow worker’s demand, 1980s-style? (3-3)
NEW-AGE Where to find Jarrow and the demand of workers there
2d Good egg flips worthless (6)
TINPOT A reversal (flips) of a synonym for good and an insect egg
3d Discussed Mrs Lovett’s speciality line beside Tower (5)
PYLON A homophone (discussed) of the speciality of Sweeney Todd’s accomplice, Mrs Lovett, the abbreviation for Line and a preposition meaning beside

4d Recipe I supply; do I supply les ingrédients? (7)
EPICIER An anagram (supply) of RECIPE I gives the name of a shop where a French cook might purchase their ingredients
6d Competitive board meeting standard of e.g. Brie at reception? (9)
PARCHEESI A norm or standard and a homophone (at reception) of a word meaning having the nature of Brie for example

7d Units excitedly deal in preserves (8)
CANDELAS An anagram (excitedly) of DEAL inserted into preserves in tins
8d Comparatively formal medic closes series on cooking (8)
DRESSIER An abbreviated medic covers (closes in a Down solution) an anagram (on cooking) of SERIES
11d Mimic of gastronomy? Naturally (4)
MYNA Hidden in the last two words of the clue
15d Buffet by rail ultimately better value – and, like Across answers, one has the pick (5,4)
EARLY BIRD An anagram (buffet) of BY RAIL and the ultimate letters of betteR, valuE, and anD

17d Goes hunting game, wanting one? (8)
GUNSIGHT An anagram (game) of GoeS HUnTING without (wanting) the letters ONE
18d Declining light object into which one tipped juice (4-4)
DEMI-JOUR A verb meaning to object into which is inserted the Roman numeral for one and a reversed (tipped) abbreviation for a juice made from a particular fruit
20d Tea for two cents no longer available, which is funny (2-2)
HA-HA Two lots of another name for tea without the abbreviation for Cents
21d Campbell’s vegetable corporation goes short (7)
TUMSHIE Campbell being the name of a Scottish clan. The solution is a Scottish word for a turnip or swede. An informal name for the stomach (corporation) and goes or has an attempt without the final letter (short)

22d Why does it matter pork supplier’s taken over Derby? (2,4)
SO WHAT A female supplier of pork and a type of headwear such as a Derby
23d Chap enjoyed dish, rather lacking out of the oven? (6)
HEATED A phrase (2.3.4)meaning chap enjoyed dish without (lacking) the suffix meaning rather or somewhat
26d A record for starters at Nando’s, not at Leon (5)
ANNAL Solved as I was writing the clue on the print out – the starters of At Nando’s Not At Leon
A tour de force by Elgar today, getting a themed item into every one of the across answers (and two in 29a).
I needed to verify several of the answers including the 28a bird, the 6d game and the 21d vegetable.
I particularly liked 12a, 16a, 18d and 22d.
Many thanks to Elgar for the proper Toughie and to CS for the review.
Got off to a reasonable start, then hit the buffers with some answers being words I’ve never heard of.
All very clever, but containing too many obscurities for me to say I particularly enjoyed this.
On the plus side, I liked our fourth drink in 12a Fray Bentos in 14&21a and the off table artichoke in 16a.
My thanks to Elgar and CS.
Phew, that was hard! Just about limped over the finishing line but only with Sue’s help in the NE. Not sure whether enjoyed is the right word but a certain satisfaction in completing it. As Gazza said, getting a themed item into every across clue is quite something and I can only marvel at Elgar’s skills!
Thanks to Elgar and Sue’s much needed hints.
Off to a flying start but defeated by the SW corner which was back to 6*. The other 3 were much more tractable, say 3*, 4*, 4* clockwise. As Gazza says – a veritable tour-de-force with a theme I totally failed to spot, despite wondering what 15d was all about.
I laughed at the devious chicken at 9a and the chopped artichoke at 16a. Also admired the elegant surface of 22d.
Thanks to Elgar and to Sue for explaining it all.
Wow!
Was looking forward to my next Elgar, having smugly completed 12 unaided clues on the last one. Talk about pride going before a fall…… two answers on my first pass, two more with electronic help, two bung-ins before I caved and sought the assistance of the blog. What amazing clues – I am thoroughly in awe of the setter, crypticsue and anyone else who completed this challenge.