Toughie 3505 – Big Dave's Crossword Blog
View closed comments 

Toughie 3505

Toughie No 3505 by Chalicea
Hints and tips by Whybird

+ – + – + – + – + – + – + – +

BD Rating – Difficulty **  – Enjoyment *****

Wimbledon’s started, the clouds have come rolling in… All’s normal!  Chalicea has given us a real Tuesday treat – perfectly pitched to start the Toughie week. There are quite a few gimmes, a friendly grid and a few requiring a bit of thought.  No grit, no pearls…  On top of that, the surfaces and concise clues make this an absolute joy.  I found I was repeating myself with typing “another splendid surface” such is the frequency and quality.  It’s hard to pick favourites out of such a quality bunch, but I’m giving rosettes to 1d, 9a and 26a.  Thank you, Chalicea, for an absolute belter.

Please leave a comment telling us how you fared and what you liked about the puzzle.

Across Clues
1 Factions prospering surprisingly with kinky lust included (8,6)

SPLINTER GROUPS An anagram of both “prospering” (surprisingly) and “lust” (kinky… …included) gives a type of faction associated with different, more extreme views than others of their cohort.

9 Initially delayed, relative from America shows heart (7)

NUCLEUS Take a male relative (neatly, one associated with the personification of America), move the first letter back one space (initially delayed) and follow that with the common two letter abbreviation for America to get a synonym of “heart”.  My last one in.  It took me a while to mentally move the comma back a word.

10 On seabed essentially solitary gastropod (7)

ABALONE A type of shellfish is formed from the central letters (essentially) of “seabed” followed by what you are if you are solitary .

11 Some codlings for food fish (4)

LING A type of edible fish is (not very obscurely) hidden (some) in “codlings”.

12 Insult about jaunt, it can be illuminating (5,5)

STRIP LIGHT Insert a four-letter synonym for “jaunt” into a six-letter insult (also meaning insubstantial) to get a type of illumination.

14 Struggle with compilers welcomed by tense solver occasionally (6)

TUSSLE How Chalicea may describe herself and her fellow compilers as a two-letter grammatic object inserted into the usual abbreviation for “tense” and the “occasional” (in this case, odd) letters of “solver” gives a synonym for “struggle”.

15 In good shape, journalist’s well-versed (8)

INFORMED A (2,4) term meaning “in good shape” (often used to describe sportspeople performing at the top of their games) followed by the usual journalist to get an adjective meaning knowledgeable.

17 Protest about renegade politician (8)

DEMOCRAT One of the two main US political parties is formed from a charade of a four letter protest (march), the letter meaning “about” and a three-letter (rodent) “renegade”.

18 Professional not running at once (6)

PRONTO The usual abbreviation for “professional” followed by an anagram (running) of “not” gives a synonym of “at once”.

21 Garden planner secures thorny shrub (10)

LANDSCAPER A type of garden designer, typically associated with larger-scale work is formed from a charade of a “secures” (what an aircraft does) and a type of thorny shrub, more associated (in my mind) with tartare sauce.

22 Red coach in street? Look to board it (4)

SLOT Insert the two letter poetic “look” into the usual abbreviation for street to get the surname of the head coach of a well-known football team. And, boy, does this hurt for a Blue….

24 Hyper active, he got on exceptionally (2,3,2)

ON THE GO An anagram (exceptionally) of “he got on” gives a synonym of “(hyper) active”.  I’m not sure the “hyper” is needed for the clue, but it does help the surface.

25 A solitary person getting married inside can become a social worker (7)

ALMONER Insert the abbreviation for “male” into “a” from the clue and what a solitary person may be described as (see 10a) to get a (hospital) social worker.  Not an insect, for once, and I did not know this context, although I knew the word from its charitable sense.

26 Responsibility for business creating proper riot on vessel (14)

PROPRIETORSHIP What you can be said to have if you own a business is made up of an anagram of “proper riot” and a four-letter sailing vessel, “creating” here being a reverse anagram indicator. It’s a lovely word, and a great surface.

Down Clues
1 Vest is and has this, as opposed to mitten? (7)

SINGLET A type of vest, and split (6,1) is also a description of one of its consonants that “mitten” has more of. Very clever, but not easy to write out concisely!

2 Trickily she controls men’s fictitious fantasy (4,4,7)

LOCH NESS MONSTER An anagram (trickily) of “she controls men’s” gives a mythical (or maybe not!) resident of one of Scotland’s bodies of water.

3 Have occasion for knee bend now and then (4)

NEED A synonym for “have occasion for” is found in the alternating letters (in this case even) letters (now and then) of “knee bend”.

4 Artificial spiders at zoology exhibits (6)

ERSATZ A word meaning “artificial” is lurking (exhibits) in “spiders at zoology”. A lovely surface.

5 Inclination to wither in allotment (8)

GRADIENT A (topographic) “inclination” is formed by inserting a three-letter cessation of life (what happens to a plant that withers, more than a direct synonym) into a synonym of “allotment” in the sense of “allowance” – beloved of students of times past. Another lovely surface.

6 Legally analogous with how most animals move (2,3,5)

ON ALL FOURS.  A double definition, and one to rattle the cage of the 20 downs of the world.  The first is a legal term meaning at worst “so near as to make no difference”, the second assumes that most animals are quadrupedal.  Edwina Currie might have saved herself a lot of bother using “many” instead of “most” but let’s hope the extremist entomological and arthropodological 1 acrosses aren’t looking.

7 Punch, gallon stirred with mush served up for tiller’s nosh (10,5)

PLOUGHMAN’S LUNCH An anagram (stirred) of “punch”, “gallon” and “mush” to give a traditional midday meal.

8 Fired up male, a dandyish unruly adolescent (6)

HEATED The male pronoun, “a” from the clue and the name for reputed troublemakers with a penchant for coloured drapes yields a synonym for “fired up” in the  thermal sense.  Yet another lovely surface.

13 Boycotts Dickens’s sycophantic law clerk, family reprobate (5,5)

BLACK SHEEP An ovine “family reprobate” could be, split (6,4), as the action of someone who was to shun an “ever so ‘umble” Dickensian character.

16 President on island captures a penguin species (8)

MACARONI The president of France and the usual abbreviation for “island” into which is inserted “a” from the clue to give a type of penguin.

17 Serving girl’s plaything requires work (6)

DOLLOP A four-letter toy that traditionally is associated with girls followed by a two-letter synonym of “work” gives a type of portion associated with soft food.

19 Disastrously poor cut, rocks visible on the surface (7)

OUTCROP An anagram (disastrously) of “poor cut” gives a name for rocks that you can see. 

 

20 Nitpicker troubled and in bad mood (6)

PEDANT Insert and anagram (troubled) of “and” into a common Crosswordland three-letter strop to get a name for a nitpicker.  Another super surface, all-in-all fitting beautifully as an overreaction to 6d.  And I can’t resist reusing the image Gazza posted recently, it’s so good. 

23 Ruler taken in by upset experiment (4)

EMIR A middle-eastern ruler is lurking (taken in by) in reverse (upset) within “experiment”.

 

21 comments on “Toughie 3505

  1. A perfect complement to Mr Plumb’s back pager – 1.5*/5*

    Candidates for favourite – 10, 25a, 1d, and 17d – and the winner is 17d, an intriguing word which, according to the Crimson Tome, comes to us from Norway.

    Thanks to Chalicea and Whybird.

  2. Cracking puzzle with plenty of lesser known definitions to amuse and confound, my only qualm being the awkward sounding term ‘food fish’ at 11a.
    As our blogger mentions, there are so many excellent surfaces, it’s hard to pick out just a few.
    My top three today are selected more for the amusement factor: The ‘ever so ‘umble’ hand-wringing clerk in 13d, (whose namesake was great band back in the day too, Mick Box was, and no doubt still is, a brilliant guitarist), 17d’s serving girl (I love the sound the answer makes) and the winner, 22a’s red coach.
    So much to enjoy, thanks to Chalicia and Whybird.

  3. Many thanks to Chalicea for a most enjoyable puzzle and to Whybird for the write-up.
    I’d never heard of the penguin, and that was my last one in.

  4. Excellent – Chalicea’s on fire today. 9a’s lovely, 22a’s a smiler and 1d is proper smart. Best thanks to her and Whybird.

  5. I’m much looking forward to this puzzle, by all accounts a really super one.
    I have carefully avoided looking at the review. Will save that pleasure for when I’ve completed the puzzle.
    With much appreciation in advance to both Chalicea and Whybird.

  6. Needed the hints to parse 22a as it didn’t occur to me to think of a football manager and 5d as I hadn’t heard of the legal term, I have now. An absolute pleasure to solve, brilliant. Almost impossible to pick a favourite from so many contenders but I’ll go with 1d. Thanks to Chalicea and Whybird.

  7. I only attempted this Toughie as it was promoted on the cryptic blog as being accessible. I’m so glad that I did.
    I needed the blog to parse 6d as it was new to me and also 22a as I know nothing about football managers.
    I really liked 9a, 1d, 13d and 17d.

    Thanks to Whybird and Chalicea.

    1. I’m glad you gave it a go and enjoyed it. Chalicea has done the Toughie Cause a great deal of good with this one.

  8. A tad more taxing than usual for Chalicea, with lots of amusing clues – 9a the star. Others that raised a smile included 22a [red coach? eh/ oh that coach] 1d, 2d [slightly disappointed that the solution wasn’t something a bit more fruity but the letters are what they are] and 17d [lovely word].
    Thanks to Chalicea and Whybird.

  9. My second late solve of the day but well worth finding the time for it. Beautifully crafted clues leading to an almost trouble-free solve but I did need to check on the red coach and absolutely refuse to believe that 2d is a fictitious fantasy – it was bad enough being told that there isn’t any Father Christmas! Top clues for me were 10a plus 5,13,16&17d.

    Many thanks to Chalicea and to Whybird for the review.

  10. I haven’t got time to finish this wonderful puzzle but I’m keeping it for tomorrow. I’ve solved about half and thoroughly enjoyed it so far. There’s no reason to suppose the rest will be any the less enjoyable.

    Thank you, Chalices for the fun. Thank you, Whybird for the hints, which I have not needed so far.

  11. I don’t get on very well with the Tuesday cryptic (I always seem to struggle, I don’t know why!), so I was pleased to see that Chalicea was on Toughie duty and very enjoyable it was too. Too many good clues to pick a favourite but the men’s fictitious fantasy made me chuckle!
    Thanks to Chalicea and Whybird.

  12. Who’d have believed the Italians love eating a penguin?

    Cracking puzzle!

    Thanks to Chalicea and Whybird for the blog.

  13. A great set of witty clever clues. Exactly what we like to see when we print out our daily fix.
    Thanks Chalicea and Whybird.

  14. Completed earlier today but zonked out after golf before posting. Can only endorse earlier comments – a thoroughly enjoyable solve from a fast start to a brisk finish & with ✅s all over the shop – would have been quicker had I remembered Pingu & not wasted time mentally trawling through US presidents before Emmanuel dawned on me & despite the obvious wordplay & knowing who the fella is the Red coach penny was embarrassingly slow to drop.
    Thanks to Chalicea for a super puzzle & to Whybird for an excellent review

  15. Finally completed this wonderful puzzle. All the plaudits have been stated so I will simply agree with them all.

    Thank you, Chalicea for a fun puzzle. Thank you, Whybird for the hints.

  16. I’m so pleased I printed this off and saved it for later. What a delightful Toughie!
    Oh my goodness! I have difficulty making a selection of top picks. I have a multiplicity of ticks, from which I have selected the following: 17d, 13d, 9a, 14a, and 18a. I had a good chuckle at 16d! This penguin is new to me. I thought the anagrams were excellent.
    Thank you Chalicea for a wonderful puzzle.
    And appreciative thanks to Whybird for the review. I’m not very well up on football, so am very glad to have your explanation 22a.

    1. So glad you enjoyed it, Catnap. It’s easy to focus on the bits we don’t like, and we forget how much good stuff there is. And this is one was a beacon!

      For what it’s worth, I was surprised by the football reference, but that just shows our setters are tuned in to the modern world!

  17. Whybird – many thanks for your splendid blog – so sorry it has taken me so long to thank you and those kind friends for their expression of their pleasure. The football manager who seemed to be your favourite was the tweak of one of the two assistant editors (I had a relatively humdrum clue that disobeyed one of the many rules) but I was ‘tuned enough into the sport world’ to know of him. I’ve been preoccupied with visiting US grandchildren whose plane was delayed by over an hour because of a turbulent teenager who refused to fasten her seat belt and had to be removed from the plane. 210 connecting flights, mostly missed at this end and the bags still haven’t reached us so Toughies took back seat.

    1. Thanks for posting, Chalicea. Sorry to hear about the airline horror show. I’ll keep an eye out for cathartic clues visiting hellfire and brimstone on the anti-social traveller! I’d love to know what the original clue was, and what rule was broken! I hope the remainder of your visitors’ trip has been better than the start.

Comments are closed.