Toughie No 3689 by Shabbo
Hints and tips by Whybird
+ – + – + – + – + – + – + – +
BD Rating – Difficulty */2 – Enjoyment ****
We have another excellently-clued puzzle from Shabbo today. Apart from a piece of parsing that gave me brief pause, and a piece of not-too-obscure Classical knowledge, the puzzle is very gentle. The principal issue I had was in treating Shabbo’s wonderfully constructed clues as actual crossword clues, and forcing myself to break them down into their constituents, as opposed to just taking them as statements in their own right. My favourites today, amongst many contenders, are the 1a/5a combo, 19d and 27a. Thank you (again), Shabbo, for a very enjoyable puzzle.
Please let us know how you fared and what you thought of the puzzle.
Across Clues
1a and 5a Clear hint agent might be getting warmer (7,7)
CENTRAL HEATING An anagram (might be getting) of “Clear hint agent”
5a See 1 Across
9a On-line proposal – adult left in tears? (9)
EMOTIONAL A synonym of “proposal” preceded by the usual letter to indicate something done on-line and followed by the letters indicating “adult” and “left”
10a Player works endlessly (5)
ACTOR Remove the outside letters (endlessly) from a synonym of (manufacturing) works. I can’t resist pinching Huntsman’s image, as I was looking at the same character…
11a Treasury initially went for banker (5)
TWEED The first letter (initially) of “Treasury” followed by a synonym of “went” in a lavatorial context
12a Trump, perhaps, naked in front of church property (9)
RESIDENCE The elected office occupied by Donald John from which the outside letters are removed (naked) precedes an abbreviation for the Church of England
13a Encouraged, drink wine with journalist (9)
SUPPORTED A charade of a synonym of “drink”, a fortified wine and the usual two-letter term for a journalist
16a Change popular officer’s clothes (5)
COINS Take an abbreviation for a (senior) officer, including the possessive as per the clue, then insert (clothes) a synonym of “popular”
17a Entertains topless goddesses (5)
MUSES Remove the first letter (topless) from a synonym of “Entertains”
18a Security certain to cover party after pub closes early (9)
INSURANCE A South African political “party” is inserted into a synonym of “certain” (to cover) and preceded (after) by a type of “pub” lacking its final letter (closes early)
20a Warm coat transforming hips and knees (9)
SHEEPSKIN An anagram (transforming) of “hips” and “knees”
23a Gold coin in circulation (5)
ORBIT A charade of the heraldic “gold” and an American low-value “coin”
25a Console Conservative going around prisons (5)
CAGES Take a brand of game console (associated with hedgehogs) and the letter indicating “Conservative” then reverse them (going around)
26a Dump talkative bird embraced by aristocracy? (9)
ELIMINATE A (variant spelling of a) group of birds known for mimicry is inserted into (embraced by) a term that could be used to describe the “aristocracy”
27a Stores cars in auditorium (7)
LARDERS The solution is a homophone of the plural of a Russian brand of cars
28a Occupy huge centre of Vienna at first (7)
ENGROSS Take a synonym of “huge” (one with unpleasant connotations) and precede that with the middle two letters (centre… …at first) of “Vienna”
Down Clues
1d Designs old bangers to save energy (7)
CREATES A synonym of “old bangers” in the automotive sense has the usual letter indicating “energy” inserted (to save)
2d She was petrified with tail dropping off dilapidated Boeing (5)
NIOBE An anagram (dilapidated) of “Boeing” but lacking the “g” (with tail dropping off)
3d Repair drain runs and work on small shower (9)
RAINDROPS Piece together an anagram (Repair) of “drain”, the usual abbreviation for “runs”, a two-letter synonym of “work” and the letter indicating “small”
4d Introvert embracing cardinal with both hands (5)
LONER A cardinal number is surrounded by the abbreviations for the two hands (or sides)
5d Bluffs and conceals overwhelming ailments (9)
HILLSIDES Take a synonym of “conceals” and insert (overwhelming) a synonym of “ailments”
6d Poster about conflict getting accolade (5)
AWARD A two-letter (promotional) poster surrounds (about) a synonym of “conflict” as a noun
7d Plan camping – no one turned up (9)
INTENTION A (2,4) statement of where you may be said to be if you are “camping” followed by an inversion (“turned up” in a Down clue) of no” from the clue, and the letter that resembles the number “one”
8d Study probing fish in Kew? (7)
GARDENS A synonym of “Study” “in the “room” sense) in inserted (probing) into the plural of a species of long-bodied fish
14d Traveller with new green permit put at the front (9)
PASSENGER An anagram (new) of “green” is preceded by (put at the front) a synonym of “permit” as a noun
15d Kitchen cooked seconds showing consistency (9)
THICKNESS An anagram (cooked) of “Kitchen” followed by two instances (the plural is used) of the letter indicating “second”
16d Rusting company car with dog promoting love (9)
CORRODING The usual two-letter “Company” is followed by the abbreviations for a brand of luxury car and then a species of antipodean dog with the letter resembling “love” (or zero) moved to the front (“promoting”)
17d Michigan getting to grips with American state performance (7)
MUSICAL Take the abbreviation for “Michigan”, insert (getting to grips with) an abbreviation for “American” and then add a three-letter abbreviation for another American state
19d Pronounced how dishes might be carried for starters (7)
ENTREES A (2,5) description of how a waiter, for example, may carry dishes sounds like (pronounced) these “starters”
21d Group pressure upset oil company (5)
POSSE The usual letter indicating “pressure” is followed by a reversal (“upset”) of a major oil company
22d Green water on the rise (5)
NAIVE A brand of mineral water is reversed (“on the rise” in a Down clue)
24d Maybe another entertaining comic (5)
BEANO The solution is lurking (entertaining) amongst the letters of “Maybe another”






Lovely puzzle, very gentle but hugely enjoyable and I hope it gets the wide audience it deserves. Could as easily have been in a prime back page spot.
Super surfaces and plenty of amusement throughout.
Many thanks indeed to Shabbo and Whybird
Shabbo never disapppoints! A gentle start to this week’s Toughie experience – */****
Candidates for favourite – 11a, 13a, 17a, 8d, and 22d – and the winner is the ‘third formish’ 11a.
Thanks to Shabbo and Whybird.
What a brilliant crossword, thanks Shabbo! So many good clues, I couldn’t possibly pick a favourite. It’s a shame it’s not a backpager really, a crossword this good deserves a wider readership.
Thanks too to Whybird for the blog which I enjoyed reading and agree with your opening comments.
The perfect mid-week back-pager, the only pause for thought being to wonder whether the fish in 8d needed the S to be plural. Apparently the name can be plural with or without the S.
According to the Puzzles Newsletter “Toughies are nowhere near as tough as their name suggests” which, apart from last Friday’s Elgar, would certainly seem to explain why so many of the recent puzzles in the middle of the paper haven’t lived up to the original description of the Toughie as the most fiendish crossword on Fleet Street, but have just provided a second ‘normal’ cryptic crossword
Thank you to Shabbo for the great crossword and to Whybird for the blog
I agree with the above. Would be perfect for a Friday back pager.
Well constructed clues and some clever misdirection throughout.
1a, 5a, 11a, 25a and 5d favourites today.
Thanks to Shabbo and Whybird
Superb! Not tough but supremely enjoyable with smooth surfaces and clean cluing all the way.
Bravo, Shabbo, many thanks and please keep them coming!
Thanks too to Whybird.
Beautifully constructed, with not a duff surface to be found.
I agree with comments above, if solvers are deterred by the ‘Toughie’ label, they are missing out big-time. After all, if you don’t attempt ’em, you’ll never finish ’em and you’ve got this site for assistance.
I can’t look past the naked Trump in front of church property at 12a as my COTD, though I wish I could!
Great fun, my thanks to Shabbo and Whybird.
That was fun! No disrespect to anyone…but if I can do it in 45 minutes….it can’t be that much of a Toughie! Only had trouble with the 2d Greek lady and the 11a lavatorial clue! Am a-waiting harder challenges as the weeeeeek progresses!
I enjoyed this more than the one on t’other side. Some really good clues with great surfaces. Shabbo is rapidly joining my list of favourite compilers. What possessed me to put “Trent” in at 11a I will never know. The actual answer raised a huge grin on this haggard old face. The naked Trump at 12a is my COTT.
Thank you, Shabbo for the fun. Thank you, Whybird for the hints.