Toughie No 3697 by Dada
Hints and tips by Whybird
+ – + – + – + – + – + – + – +
BD Rating – Difficulty ** – Enjoyment ***
Well this is a genuine Toughie, no worries on that score. I thought the difficulty level was perfectly pitched for a Tuesday. There is plenty of Dada’s characteristic, quirky clueing and if his name hadn’t been plastered across the top of the page, I would have ventured a few small coins on the setter’s identity and been correct for once. 23a piqued my Inner Pedant, 5d gave it a hard poke, and I’ve abraded the top of my head a little trying to parse 25d. 12a made me smile, I liked 14d’s structure, as well as the solution being a great word, but the clear winner of my Gold Star today is the clever, smooth-surfaced 15d. Thanks to Dada for making the Tuesday morning tea work somewhat harder than of late.
Please let us know how you fared and what you thought of the puzzle.
Across Clues
1a Kick up a fuss with loud music beat and hot dancing (4,3,4)
ROCK THE BOAT A type of music often associated with a lot of volume followed by an anagram (dancing) of “beat” and “hot”
10a Marks printed in file bookkeeper returned (5)
OBELI The solution is hidden (in) in reverse (returned) amongst ”file bookkeeper”. The clue also works as just “Marks”
11a Flute for example sings almost all we played (9)
WINEGLASS An anagram (played) of “sings”, the first two letters of “all” (almost all) and “we”
12a False teeth in twice – for this birthday? (9)
NINETIETH An anagram (False) of “teeth” and “in in” (in twice)
13a Tropical tree with a brick knocked over (5)
BALSA Reverse (knocked over) “a” from the clue and a synonym of “brick”
14a Temple facing the wrong way, plain vulgar (6)
TAWDRY Reverse (facing the wrong way) a Thai word meaning “Temple” and append a synonym of “plain” as an adjective
16a Lothario so, an eccentric overcome by drink (8)
CASANOVA An anagram (eccentric) of “so an” is inserted into (overcome by) a Spanish sparkling wine
18a Whole clue initially lacking? Flipping great! (8)
INTEGRAL Start with a synonym of “clue”, remove the first letter (initially lacking) and then append a reversal (Flipping) of a synonym of “great” in the sense of size
20a Canard followed by ostentatiously good seafood dish (6)
SCAMPI A charade of a synonym of “Canard” (or fraud) followed by Crosswordland’s favourite term meaning “ostentatiously good” (better known as a Greek letter and geometric ratio)
23a Itinerant fed by king and a nineteenth-century monarchy (5)
BURMA Take a (principally American) synonym of “Itinerant” (or tramp), insert (fed by) a letter than can indicate “king” then append “a” from the clue to give a country whose monarchy ended in the 19th Century, so clearly was a monarchy for most of the 19th century, but which had also been a monarchy for many centuries before then
24a Old weapon, pest by unconscious design? (9)
DOODLEBUG A charade of a synonym of “unconscious design” (eg a drawing whilst distracted) and a three-letter synonym of “pest”
26a Action due, miscreant admonished (9)
CAUTIONED An anagram (miscreant) of “Action due”. I’m not totally convinced by “miscreant” as an anagram indicator as it is neither a verb nor an adjective, but it is clear enough (although “admonished” is a more likely anagram indicator and had me barking up the wrong tree for a while
27a Gold bit in lecture (5)
ORATE A charade of the heraldic “Gold” and a synonym of “bit” in the sense of consumed food
28a Definitely how to get six runs? (2,1,4,4)
BY A LONG SHOT Almost a double definition. The answer here is also what you could be said to have employed to score six runs in a single cricket stroke.
Down Clues
2d Lyric work concerned with theatre (5)
ODEON A charade of a type of “lyric work” and a two-letter synonym of “concerned with”
3d Trinket thrown for craftsperson (7)
KNITTER An anagram (thrown) of “Trinket”
4d Werewolf’s gaffe? (6)
HOWLER A double definition, the first sense being a cryptic way to describe a werewolf based on sound
5d Idiot, manager of skeleton staff? (8)
BONEHEAD Another “almost double definition” the answer also being a cryptic description of someone in charge of a constituent of a skeleton. To me, a skeleton comprises more than one of these constituents, but I think the question mark blurs the lines enough
6d Subject with a fractured leg and vital organ dropping in (7)
ALGEBRA Start with “a” from the clue, add an anagram (fractured) of “leg” then a major organ from which the letters “in” have been removed (dropping in)
7d Where Americans go with vessel on small river for author (4,9)
JOHN STEINBECK A charade of an American term for a toilet, a large drinking vessel and a synonym of a small river
8d Everyone parting leaves clearer space for dance (8)
BALLROOM Insert a synonym of “everyone” into a tool that may be used to tidy up leaves, amongst other things. There’s one under construction down Pennsylvania Avenue.
9d To a limited degree, where that train perhaps terminates? (2,3,2,2,4)
AS FAR AS IT GOES Another almost double definition, the solution also being a cryptic definition of the end of a train’s journey
15d Vehicle was crossing river in replacement of Tube (5,3)
WATER BUS Start by putting the letter indicating “river” into an anagram (replacement) of “Tube”. This is then surrounded by “was” from the clue (was crossing). A wonderfully-well constructed clue
17d Kind of point in flier (8)
CARDINAL A double definition
19d Force acting upon Newton’s apple sauce, it being eaten (7)
GRAVITY Take a synonym of “sauce” and insert “it” from the clue (it being eaten)
21d Cold, hard skin pierced by nothing (7)
CALLOUS A term for “hard skin” has inserted (pierced by) the letter that resembles the numeric “nothing”
22d Gracious teacher in line (6)
CORDON A charade of an exclamation meaning “Gracious” and a synonym of “teacher” (or academic)
25d Shindig: stand for it not happening? (5)
BEANO I’ve struggled with parsing this, and the best I’ve come up with is that if you split the answer (2,1,2) it would represent (stand for) a possible partial negative reply to the question “Is this shindig happening?” as in “that would xx x xx”








An enjoyable and amusing start to the toughie week.
The birthday at 12a was fun, I recall as a kid being aware old people put their false Hampsteads in a jar by the side of the bed at night. I do hope modern dentistry has rendered this charming practice somewhat unnecessary nowadays.
The itinerant in 23a was surely an unidentified American, while where he’d go in 7d with his vessel on a small river made me laugh.
Newton’s apple sauce in 19d was fun too.
Like our blogger, I’m also unsure about 25d.
My thanks to Dada and Whybird.
Gentle fun, about right for a Tuesday toughie. My ticks go to 12a,18a, and 15d. I parsed 25d exactly as presented in the hints.
Thanks to Dada and Whybird.
I get the feeling that Dada is being gradually let off the leash at Telegraph Towers (which is to be applauded). I enjoyed this puzzle – thanks to him and Whybird.
I parsed 25d the same as our reviewer.
I particularly liked 18a, 24a, 4d, 7d and 8d.
Why is cardinal synonym for flier?
Cardinals are a family of birds, as illustrated.
Reasonably accessible and fun too. 15d was my last in and very good and I liked the helpful long ‘uns around the edges, particularly the means of scoring a six at 28a and the destination at 9d. Thanks very much to Dada and to Whybird.
Agreed, just right for a Tuesday. Agreed re 25d [and my head needed some scratching too] My top picks were 12a and 15d, which illustrate the fact that anagram clues can be top quality if done well despite what some solvers and setters seem to think. Apropos FrankieM’s remarks about false teeth – yes, removeable dentures can now be “replaced” by fixed bridges and implants but you have to sell your vinyl to afford them, I know.
Thanks to Dada and Whybird.