A Puzzle by Ruskin
+ – + – + – + – + – + – + – + – + – +
The puzzle is available by clicking on the above grid.
As usual, the setter will be delighted to receive feedback from you, the solvers. We do ask that you remember that for most setters this is a new experience, so please only offer constructive criticism.
Ruskin make a barnstorming debut in the Rookie corner. There was a high degree of technical ability on display and the clues read smoothly. The comments on the clues are minor ones to provide gilding on the lily. The commentometer reads as 2.5/33 or 7.6%.
Across
9a Press release that is covering introduction of congestion charge (5)
PRICE: The abbreviations for press release and for “that is” around (covering) the first letter (introduction) of congestion.
10a United advanced by turning rude and aggressive (9)
TRUCULENT: The abbreviation for united and a four-letter word meaning advanced after (by) a reversal (turning) of a four-letter word meaning rude.
11a Old fashioned pair of Conservatives guzzling drink half naked (9)
CLASSICAL: The abbreviation for Conservative twice (pair of) includes a five-letter word for an Indian yoghurt drink and is followed by the middle letters (naked) of half.
12a Middle of the road boring angry vacuous writer (5)
HARDY: The middle letter of “the” followed by the abbreviation for road inside (boring) the outer letters (vacuous) of angry.
13a Basin filled by water main next to flat (4,3)
DEAD SEA: A three-letter word for a body of water (main) after (by) a four-letter word meaning flat or lifeless.
15a Has previously plunged into river in Kentish Town? (7)
CHATHAM: An old (previously) four-letter form of the verb to have inside a three-letter name of a river running through a university city.
17a ‘Production‘ and ‘work’ are different; (5)
OPERA: The two-letter abbreviation for work followed by an anagram (different) of ARE.
18a Oh – you are caught being owned by us (3)
OUR: A homophone (caught) of the first three words of the clue.
20a Mumble about accepting English customs (5)
RULES: A reversal (about) of a four-letter word meaning to mumble around (accepting) the abbreviation for English.
22a Spot of ‘The Rest is Cryptic’ for armchair enthusiasts? (7)
SITTERS: An anagram (cryptic) of T (spot or first letter of The) REST IS.
25a There’s a speck of light shimmering in harbour (7)
SHELTER: An anagram (shimmering) of THERES L (a speck or first letter of light). Perhaps having two clues one after the other with the identical wordplay structure is not ideal.
26a Amusement is essential to Robin Goodfellow (5)
BINGO: The answer is hidden (is essential to) in the final two words of the clue. Ideally, essential to should be used to indicate the exact middle of a word or sequence of words.
27a Tom’s Diner rewritten in the style of Virginia Woolf (9)
MODERNIST: An anagram (rewritten) of TOMS DINER.
30a Hopper initially goes through brown period – his colour can change (9)
CHAMELEON: The first letter (initially) of hopper inside (goes through) a five-letter word for a type of light brown followed by a three-letter word for a long period of time.
31a Conclusion of radio debate – firing a vintage weapon (5)
ORGUE: The final letter (conclusion) of radio followed by a five-letter word meaning to debate without (firing) the letter A.
Down
1d Brief description of boundless view (4)
SPEC: A six-letter word for a view without the outer letters (boundless).
2d Reverend’s address about wrath follows verse one (8)
VICARAGE: A two-letter word for about and a four-letter word for wrath after (follows) the abbreviation for verse and the letter represented by one.
3d Legends of the ancient king rearing son (4)
KEYS: The two-letter old (ancient) form of the and the chess abbreviation for king reversed (rearing) followed by the abbreviation for son.
4d Detached house regularly in a spin including pet running up and down; (8)
STACCATO: A reversal (in a spin) of the even letters (regularly) of house include a three-letter feline pet and its reversal (running up and down).
5d People rolled up and raised just over a hundred pounds (6)
PUBLIC: A reversal (rolled) of the UP from the clue and another way of writing 101 pounds avoirdupois.
6d Actor’s vehicle discussed by hack on podcast (4,6)
HUGH LAURIE: A homophone (discussed) of lorry (vehicle) after (by) a homophone (on podcast) of hew (hack). Perhaps having three clues in the crossword of the form A by B with by operating as a positional indicator is overusing the device.
7d Piece of Apache art hanging in symbolic place (6)
HEARTH: The answer is hidden (piece of) in the third to fifth words of the clue.
8d Lose your way without right support (4)
STAY: A five-letter word meaning lose your way without the abbreviation for right.
13d They help you get through the same old empty routines (5)
DOORS: The abbreviation for ditto (the same) followed by the abbreviation for old and the outer letters (empty) of routines.
14d Undersized reproduction cellos made in error (5,5)
SCALE MODEL: An anagram (in error) of CELLOS MADE.
16d Scrooge is wrestling with Marley on a regular basis (5)
MISER: An anagram (wrestling) of IS MRE (the odd letters – on a regular basis – of Marley). Having used regularly as an alternate letter indicator in 4d, perhaps a different word should have been used here to avoid repeating wordplay indicators.
19d 8/(i + 25) is settled (8)
RESIDENT: A four-letter word that is a synonym for the answer to 8a includes (/ or divided by) the I from the clue and a three-letter word that is a synonym for the answer to 25a.
21d Badly lit gents is landlord’s responsibility (8)
LETTINGS: An anagram (badly) of LIT GENTS.
23d Covering which protects hip (3,3)
TIN HAT: A four-letter word meaning which around (protects) a two-letter word meaning fashionable or hip).
24d Beginning to sense murmurs of unease about mega hot spell (6)
SUMMER: The initial letter (beginning to) of sense followed by two two-letter words expressing hesitation (murmurs of unease) around (about) the abbreviation for mega.
26d Champion US football player tosses coin (4)
BACK: A ten-letter word for a position of a player in American football without (tosses) the name of a US coin. Perhaps some indication that it is both the football player and the coin that are American would be helpful. “…tosses his coin” would do this.
28d ‘REX’ written over lion’s head in tapestry-maker’s margin (4)
ROOM: The abbreviation for Rex replaces (written over) the first letter (head) of lion in a four-letter word for a frame used in tapestry making.
29d One’s leafy Essex community losing its mind (4)
TREE: A nine-letter word for a town in Essex without the initial five-letters meaning mind.
![crossword-logo[1]](https://i0.wp.com/bigdave44.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/crossword-logo1.jpeg?resize=96%2C96)
Welcome to Rookie Corner Ruskin. A quite challenging puzzle for me although it did raise smiles for 15a, 30a, 31a, 1d, 3d, and 13d.
The ‘ ’ in 17a and 4d, in the pdf, was a little confusing and the, for me, obscure drink in 11a slowed me down and became a ‘bung in’ that needed BRB and e-verification.
There is usually a particular use of essential which is not how you have used it in 26a. It is used to indicate the central letter in a word with an odd number of letters or central two letters in a word with an even number of letters.
Thanks Ruskin and thanks in advance to Prolixic.
The ‘ ’ is on me. With its final semicolon it’s the HTML code for a non-breaking space. Rogue HTML characters sometimes creep into the publication puzzles when I convert them from whatever format setters supply them in. I look for such errors but missed the two today because they were tucked away at the end of clues. I’ve now uploaded corrected copies of all puzzle files.
Re 26a “essential” is often used to mean central letters, but in this format “is essential to” = “is necessary / required in order to make” … which is a different usage (ie just a hidden) but arguably more accurate / less whimsical, using the everyday meaning of “essential” rather than a linguistic ‘trick’?
There are lots of very clever clues in this one and it kept us working hard for quite some time. Eventually gave up and revealed to get 28d. It was all a bit more difficult than we like to see in Rookie Corner but obviously written by a very competent setter.
Thanks Ruskin.
Welcome to Rookie Corner, Ruskin. My experience mirrors that of the 2Kiwis even needing to reveal the two unchecked letters to find the answer to 28d in order to get a full grid. In addition, I can’t parse 24d and 26d.
I agree with Senf about 26a. “Essential” means either the single middle letter or middle two letters of a word.
I can’t make much sense of the surface reading of 22a but, other than that, your surfaces are generally smooth, which is encouraging to see, particularly on debut. That makes me suspect this is not your first ever cryptic puzzle.
15a was my favourite of several ticked clues.
Well done and thank you, Ruskin. Please make your next submission a little more solver friendly. Thanks too in advance to Prolixic.
24d I take the ‘murmurs of unease’ to be um and er.
26d Tosses coin means remove ‘quarter’.
Thanks, Gazza.
“Champion football (or rugby) player” would have sufficed for 26d!
I wrote quite a long comment which appears to have disappeared into the ether so I’ll try and remember what I said and start again
Welcome to Rookie Corner Ruskin and thank you for what I thought was a very difficult crossword – I had to reveal quite a few letters in order to finish. Please take note of the comments and the wise words of Prolixic, and come back with something a lot more solver-friendly next time
I see one of your crosswords is featured in the My Crossword spot on 15sq today – I have a long to do list but will see if I can find time later to solve it and then compare and contrast
This is a very competent (and quite tricky) debut puzzle in Rookie Corner. I enjoyed it – many thanks to Ruskin.
Ticks from me for 12a, 15a, 2d, 6d and 26d.
Hello Ruskin.
Not really a typical “rookie” I think, with contributions already to MyCrossword and Unch magazine, but you are very welcome here.
I too found this tough, but I think that was due more to unfamiliarity with the setter’s style than the wordplay being especially devious, although several clues were very tricky to parse.
Like last week’s puzzle, technically it is of a very high quality and the surface readings are excellent, so I think your appearances in this particular slot may prove to be brief. Favourite clue for me was 29d.
Congratulations on an impressive puzzle, Ruskin, and many thanks.
Thank you for your puzzle, Ruskin, which we did find difficult and we needed several reveals because of the clever misdirection. Please make your next one more solver friendly. Favourites were 13a, 30a, 2d and 29d. Thanks in advance to Prolixic who will enlighten us with some of the parsing tomorrow.
Really enjoyed your rather accomplished challenge, Ruskin, thank you. I couldn’t parse my answer to 28d but it “had to be”, and couldn’t get center back out of my mind for 26d, which made that parsing awkward too!
Your particular use of “essential” was familiar from cryptics elsewhere so the fact that it wasn’t exactly in the middle didn’t bother me.
COTD for me was 23d, but in my margins there were many ticks and no crosses.
Very well done and thank you, with thanks also to Prolixic.