A Puzzle by Dr Weevil
+ – + – + – + – + – + – + – + – + – +
The puzzle is available by clicking on the above grid.
As usual, the setter will be delighted to receive feedback from you, the solvers. We do ask that you remember that for most setters this is a new experience, so please only offer constructive criticism.
A review of this puzzle will be added tomorrow (Tuesday).
![crossword-logo[1]](https://i0.wp.com/bigdave44.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/crossword-logo1.jpeg?resize=96%2C96)
Many thanks to the blog for publishing another of my efforts. I found the feedback for my first puzzle (provided by Prolixic and other commenters) both constructive and insightful; my hope is that I’ve succeeded in correcting some of my earlier mistakes with this new attempt, and that it’ll be fairer on the solvers this time!
Thanks Dr Weevil for an enjoyable conclusion to my abbreviated weekend of Cruciverbalism.
Smiles for 11a, 21a, 8d (very educational!), and 19d.
Thanks again and thanks in advance to Prolixic.
Thanks Senf. I’m delighted to read that you found the puzzle enjoyable.
Also I find it genuinely fascinating to learn which clues were people’s favourites, so thanks for that.
We were quite slow to get started but when we had a few answers and managed to get on the setter’s wave-length, solved at a steady pace.
We ended up with no question marks left on our pages and thoroughly enjoyed the process. Two thumbs up from us for a top quality set of excellent clues.
Many thanks and well done Dr Weevil.
Thanks 2Kiwis for your lovely vote of confidence. I’m touched to read that you had a: ‘thoroughly enjoyable’ experience!
Welcome back to Rookie Corner, Dr Weevil, with an accomplished puzzle which was nicely challenging and much more accessible than your debut submission.
I’m not sure that you can use “initiate” in 27a as an instruction to take the first letters of the preceding words. I’ll be interested to learn Prolixic’s take on this.
Although the definition and answer are obvious, I don’t understand the wordplay for 2d.
Some of your surface readings were less than convincing. I think this should be the main area for you to work on in future.
Many thanks for a very enjoyable solve, Dr W. I look forward to your next offering, Thanks too in advance to Prolixic.
Thanks Rabbit Dave for taking the time to solve another of my efforts, and for your considered and constructive feedback.
I’m also unsure about the use of: ‘initiate’ there! My intention was that it should be read as the imperative of the verb, i.e. as an instruction to manipulate the preceding words in that way. I definitely wasn’t sure if I’d managed to construct it correctly though, so I also eagerly await Prolixic’s verdict!
In 2d, the first word is the definition, and then the whole of the rest is intended to be read (without the original punctuation) as: ‘you’ll find them close to evens.’ I don’t know whether that is helpful, or if it still doesn’t work for you?
Completely agree that i have work to do on improving surface readings. It’s an area where I feel I’m quite capable of ‘talking myself into it,’ as it were. There are definitely cases where I’ll convince myself it reads ok, but only by giving the phrase a very particular variation of stresses etc. I do then wonder if I’m requiring the solver to do too much mental work to read it as something meaningful. So it’s extremely useful to learn that you did, indeed, find some of them less than convincing, thanks for that. I find it really satisfying when everything falls into place with just the right vocabulary etc. to create a good surface reading, but need to get there a bit more consistently!
Thanks again.
Many thanks for your response, Dr W, and willingness to take on board the comments to help your continued improvement.
Thanks too for your explanation of the wordplay for 2d. It is perfectly sound to ignore punctuation for wordplay and, although I understand your idea, I’m not entirely convinced by it,
That’s good to know, thank you. A couple of family members also struggled to parse that one. I think it’s not quite there!
For what my opinion’s worth… It’s fine for solvers to (mostly!) ignore punctuation, as the setter may be trying to be misleading with it. I don’t think it’s fine for setters to require that the solver *has* to ignore the punctuation to parse the clue correctly. I think it very much fails the second part of “you don’t have to mean what you say, but you must say what you mean”.
I’ve had a gentle ticking off from StephenL for doing this in an old NTSPP (sticking a random question mark in the middle of a clue just to make the surface work), so I’m in the habit now of checking every single piece of punctuation and making sure it works in both the surface and the cryptic grammar, otherwise get rid of it (or change the clue).
That’s a very interesting distinction that I don’t think I had fully understood yet. But I feel that the way you’ve explained it here is bringing me closer to getting it! Thanks for sharing your experienced perspective Duncan, it’s definitely something I shall endeavour to get my head around properly.
Thanks Dr Weevil for an enjoyable crossword and, in advance, to Prolixic
Thanks crypticsue for taking the time to solve another of my puzzles, and for the encouraging feedback! Very pleased to hear you found it enjoyable.
An enjoyable puzzle pitched at just the right level – thanks Dr Weevil.
There are a couple of clues (14d and 18d) where the part of speech of the definition doesn’t match that of the answer.
Top clues for me were 13a, 21a and 22a.
Thanks Gazza! Pitching it at a fairer level was the main thing I was trying to improve on after reading the feedback from my first puzzle; it’s encouraging to see that people here generally seem to agree that this was successful.
You’re absolutely correct about the parts of speech in 14d & 18d. In both of these, I was attempting to use the device of defining a noun through a verbal phrase (as mentioned in Prolixic’s setting guide). It’s entirely possible that I’ve not managed to execute this device correctly!
Thanks again.
Thank you very much for the puzzle, Dr Weevil.
Having seen your reply to RD about “initiate”, one cannot put imperative instructions AFTER the words concerned, they must precede them. For that reason, 27a doesn’t work, unfortunately. Also the definition for 18d clues a verb rather than a noun, adding “one” at the beginning of the clue would solve the problem. 14d has a similar flaw. A four-letter anagram like 24d where only one letter changes position isn’t the best idea, that was definitely your weakest clue, in my opinion.
Those clues apart, the other issue on which to improve would be the surface readings, as RD rightly says. None are terrible, but quite a few were certainly unconvincing and could be smoother methinks. There were lots of good ideas on display, that bodes well.
Like last week’s setter, I really applaud your willingness to engage with solvers and improve, it does you great credit. I look forward to your next one.
Many thanks silvanus, for your detailed and constructive feedback.
It’s very helpful to have the clarification of how the imperative ought to be used, I’ll try to avoid putting it this way round in the future. It’s great to know that you’re in agreement with other commenters about quite a few other points/areas I can improve on as well.
And your feedback for 24d makes perfect sense. I hadn’t even really considered those weaknesses when creating it, so this is another point I can hopefully be more aware of in future. Thanks again.