EV 1463 (Hints) – Big Dave's Crossword Blog
View comments 

EV 1463 (Hints)

Enigmatic Variations 1463

Drawing Parallels by Kcit

Hints and tips by The Numpties

+ – + – + – + – + – + – + – +

Kcit certainly needs no introduction for EV solvers – his challenging puzzles in all the thematic cryptic outlets (also as Phi) and in the broadsheets, where, among other appearances he is a regular Telegraph Toughie setter, stretch back over almost twenty-five years.

Preamble: Five clues each have three surplus consecutive letters, to be removed before solving; in clue order, these groups spell out what every other clue has at least one of (amended clues may not make literal sense). In the final grid a number of cells will be blank – lengths in brackets give the spaces available. Solvers must place a dot in one such cell, DRAWING PARALLELS by connecting it with lines to the four corners of the puzzle. The correct choice of blank cell will reveal a four-word phrase in the cells crossed by two of the four connecting lines. Chambers Dictionary (2016) is recommended.

There’s a lot going on here and our advice is (as usual) to pay very careful attention to the preamble. We wondered, at first, whether ‘every other clue’ could mean every second clue, but no, it means all but the five clues which have a group of three letters to be extracted from them. Since ‘amended clues’ are spoken of, we assumed that some kind of change (‘at least one of’!) was going to occur in all but five clues.

We were also warned to expect a number of blank cells so we assumed, for example, that a seven-letter solution might have eight cells available. We had to identify one of these ’empty cells’, place a dot in it and draw lines from that to the grid corners. (BE CAREFUL! Place your dot in the centre of it and draw those lines to the corners very carefully – the Numpties needed two tries to get this right). Something is going to be revealed by reading the cells two of those lines cross.

Across

5a          Savant accepting learner probing a song book (7)
We’ve commented before that editors usually prompt setters to remove ‘a’ from their clues unless it is an essential part of the wordplay. It is a strange and very adaptable word and here, since something has to ‘probe’ (or fill) it, it has to represent a longer word. Remember that we are either going to remove three letters from the clue or adapt a word or words in some way.

11a         Ill-favoured swimmer, nothing won, hiding in hut (6, two words)
We had a comical surface reading of an ugly swimmer who has lost his race and hides his shame in some hut. But then we broke down the elements of the clue producing a couple of letters from two of the words and produced our ‘ill-favoured swimmer’, an ugly creature indeed that was not familiar to us.

14a         Working form of cure mostly for Australian with disorder (5)
We have a clear hint here that we are looking for an Australian word. knowing the usual crossword word for ‘working’ and needing only three more letters gave us our way into what was going on in almost every clue of the crossword.

16a         Old guy initially aboard sports car – that is Max, perhaps (7)
Again we had to think beyond aged Max in his sportster and convert the clue to useful single letters. Remember that ‘perhaps’ in a clue suggests that the setter is ‘defining by example so ‘Max’ is an example of something. Don’t forget that some empty cells are going to appear. The intersection of across and down clues will resolve that issue (with less trouble than we initially feared).

29a         Studies around church revealing more than one hell (7)
This clue, with an apparent link word in its centre spelled out the solution for us (once we had made the adaptation that we know we are making in clues) but we needed Chambers to confirm a rather surprising plural form.

31a         Stuff to build all, I accepted, is something like mackerel (5)
Another new word for us but, as is so often the case, the word mostly appeared in the grid (towards the end of our solve) and we could consult Mrs Bradford’s Crossword Solver’s Dictionary to find a 5-letter fish.

34a        Caledonian regiment tie rating up (6)
We are evidently looking for a Scottish word for a regiment. (In fact like Spenser for English words, Sir Walter Scott is the culprit for many of the Scots words in Chambers and this is one of his). ‘Up’ is another of those words that are so popular with crossword setters. Chambers tells us that it can mean ‘amiss’ or ‘in an excited state’.

35a         Carriage leading all Scots to see bard (7)
We back-solved from our solution towards the end of our solve, remembering that there can be more than one adaptation in a clue. We needed Chambers to confirm the ‘all Scots’ element of the clue, as we did for ‘loot as before’ -a dated word produced by 36a.

Down

2d         Leader abandoning top pace (4)
We could see how the definition led to the solution here but parsing the wordplay had us puzzled and will probably puzzle you too – just an added challenge.

3d           Angler’s lie: no source of fish in historic water (7)
Again, we could see and recognise a fairly unusual word for the solution but had to back solve to parse the wordplay with that ‘historic water’ giving us a challenge.

6d         Quit place in South-East – openings in Runcorn’s skyscraper blocks (8)
Another of Kcit’s comical clue surface senses. With no disrespect to Runcorn (we are northerners) no one is likely to quit a place in the South-East for a squat in some high rise there. Of course, we needed to put together all those mini clue elements to find a word that is particularly relevant as I write.

9d         English poison bearing poisonous compounds, taking out King – no difficulty here (8)
Kings and queens appear so often because of the letters they provide for setters but here we are deleting the King from an unusual word for poisonous compounds.

16d         Listless fellow to offer ale for nocturnal type (8)
Solvers who download the crossword from the Telegraph Crossword Club (as we do) or buy the newspaper, don’t have the benefit of underlined definitions which is an aspect of Big Dave’s Crossword blog hints that probably really helps newcomers. In this clue it is useful to know that our clue elements produce a night creature of some kind. We know it with a slightly different spelling.

20d         Article on investigation overlooking Southern heaths (7)
A technical word is needed here. ‘Overlooking’ suggests omission of something.

25d        God willing to accept men? Thor in another country (5)
A two-letter abbreviation for men had to go into three other letters. We found it tough to produce those three but the letters that appeared in the grid gave us the word we were told was foreign.

27d        One old teal circling island with a sense of chill (5)
As usual, we are given an indication that an element of the wordplay is ‘archaic’ or old.

29d        Chia or chai supported by a very vulgar character (4)
You may need Chambers to explain how this clue works. Remembering the device of making one or more adaptations in most clues, and knowing your Chambers‘ abbreviations will certainly lead to an amused smile here.

Once you have spotted what is going on in the clues (and probably, as we did, worked backwards to find the fifteen letters that spelled it out) you will have been entertained by the series of deceptive verbal pictures, like that frozen old bird flapping its way round an island in 27d). With Kcit being such an old master in the crossword world, much of his language will be familiar to regular solvers, but he leaves us with a task to perform. It won’t be too difficult to decide where to put your dot, but do place it in the centre of that cell and enjoy the final penny drop moment.

Do please send in your entry and add your comments here and to the setters’ blogs that are appearing on Big Dave’s site on Thursdays and to the detailed Blogs that also appear on Thursdays on fifteensquared.


Could new readers please read the Welcome post and the FAQ before posting comments or asking questions about the site.

As this is a Prize crossword, please don’t put any ANSWERS, whether WHOLE, PARTIAL or INCORRECT, or any ALTERNATIVE CLUES in your comment.

Please read these instructions carefully – they are not subject to debate or discussion. Offending comments may be redacted or, in extreme cases, deleted. In all cases the administrator’s decision is final.


5 comments on “EV 1463 (Hints)
Leave your own comment 

  1. I’ll admit I made heavy weather of this excellent puzzle – even after reading the Numpties’ helpful hints. The “what every other clue has” penny dropped after a while which allowed me to complete the spelled-out phrase and also to spot some more “every other clue” features. At that point – and the Numpties’ references to reverse engineering suggests they were in the same boat – I found myself biffing in likely answers from the definitions and soon had a full grid. Then for the ruler work: definitely tricky but with care the final phrase was there to find and I was home. In 2d remember to locate the “every clue” feature: try the options and it will click in the end.

  2. WooWee! That was a tricky one! Stared at a blank grid for quite a while. I finally got an answer that I knew had to be the answer because the wordplay worked out so nicely…but it didn’t fit with the definition at all. Then things really started to click. About halfway through the puzzle, I gave in and looked at The Numpties hints. Glad I did — probably wouldn’t have been able to parse 34A without them.
    Thanks for the jaw-dropping challenge, Kcit! And thanks for the insightful commentary, The Numpties. See y’all next Sunday!

  3. It’s probably not a surprise that these puzzles are so much easier if you can spot the theme early. Thank you Numpties for the hint for 5a which gave me a hypothesis for the 15 letters that determine how most of the clues are to be treated. It was relatively easy to test the hypothesis by examining the clues – and away you go! Thanks also for the tip to draw the candidate lines with care – one or two cells are only just included in the final message – but it’s clear enough and, of course, completes the theme.

    Thanks to KCIT and once more to the Numpties.

  4. There’s been some discussion of the exact positioning of lines and / or dot in “another place”. Clearly it must be possible to achieve this in a way that passes through a precisely-specified group of cells or the puzzle would not be viable, and I appreciate that many among us will want to ensure just that. But I should be surprised if the first entry drawn from the hat with the dot in the right cell and the requisite lines is scrutinised with a straight-edge against this criterion but then rejected for a slight inaccuracy. (My entry has the four-word phrase scribbled above it just in case!)

    That point made, I should add that I thoroughly enjoyed the puzzle and its ingenious construction.

  5. I found this puzzle difficult to start with and spent a long time solving just a few clues. I was on the point of thinking this one’s not for me when a PDM gave me the ‘what had to happen in every other clue’ and I completed the rest (with some help from the Numpties) in a reasonable time. Regarding the positioning of the lines I assumed that the editor would be looking for the four lines to start from the correct blank square and that any minor inaccuracies would be irrelevant. However similarly to Ifor I did write the letters of the four word phrase in red ink – just in case!
    I really enjoyed this one once I got going. Thanks to Kcit for the challenge and to the Numpties for their hints.

Join the Conversation, Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.